History is full of bubbles, booms and busts, corporate collapses and crises, which illuminate the present financial world. At Stewart Investors we believe that an appreciation of financial history can make us more effective investors today.
The Whisky Bubble (1890s)
The price of any asset may be inflated to extreme levels – bonds, property, shares, tulips – whisky.1 In July 1898 the Scottish whisky firm of Pattisons announced record profits and the expansion of its Aultmore and Glenfarclas distilleries. On 24 November the Company was given a clean bill of health by its accountants. Thirteen days later Pattisons went bust, marking the end of the whisky bubble of the late 19th century. The collapse provides a number of lessons for investors.
The distilling of whisky expanded significantly during the 19th century, boosted by new technology which allowed distillers to produce larger amounts of spirit much more cheaply. Demand increased as whisky was repositioned as ‘the gentleman’s drink of choice’, replacing brandy. The expansion of the railway network across the UK improved the distribution of the product.
The 1890s were glory years for Scotch. Demand boomed in the UK and overseas and whisky barons like Buchanan, Dewar and Haig became household names. A distillery building bonanza spread across Scotland, with 39 new distilleries constructed in the decade, reaching a peak with nine being built in 1897 and ten in 1898.2 Distilled volumes rose from 44 million proof gallons (mpg) in 1893 to 63 mpg in 1899, an increase of 43% in six years.3
The Rise of Pattisons
Beginning as an Edinburgh dairy wholesaler, Pattisons diversified into blended whisky to take advantage of surging demand, when brothers Robert and Walter Pattison took over their father’s business. Initially the company purchased whisky from other distilleries and focused on the marketing of its blends, which included Morning Dew and Royal Gordon.
The rise of Pattisons was nothing short of spectacular, culminating in the flotation of the company on the London Stock Market in 1896. The share offer was six times oversubscribed, encouraging other whisky company flotations, and resulting in speculation in whisky company shares, as well as whisky itself. The brothers pocketed the large amount of £150,000 (more than £15m in today’s money)4 from the flotation, but remained in control of the company, holding all the ordinary shares and a quarter of the preference ones.
The 1890s was a decade of easy money with banks providing credit to fund deals in the whisky industry. Pattisons took advantage of this, buying their own distilling assets to secure supply. The company acquired a half share in the Glenfarclas Distillery, substantial interests in the Oban & Aultmore-Glenlivet Distilleries and the Ardgowan grain distillery, and diversified into beer production with the purchase of the Duddingston Brewery in Edinburgh. The low cost of credit made an industry such as whisky, with its large working capital requirements, especially prone to speculative investment.
Pattisons epitomised the marketing-led whisky firms of the boom years. The company reputedly spent £20,000 (£2m today) on advertising in 1897 and the vast sum, for the time, of £60,000 (£6m today) in 1898. Reportedly, 500 African Grey parrots were provided free to pubs and licenced grocers. The birds squawked ‘Pattisons whisky is best!’ and ‘Buy Pattisons whisky!’ at potential customers!5
The brothers courted publicity through their flamboyant lifestyles. Pattisons celebrated its second anniversary with a lavish party at Henley Regatta on an extravagant houseboat constructed for the occasion. The brothers hired private trains to take them back to their estates in the Borders. The Company’s headquarters in Constitution Street in Leith was described as a ‘palace’.
The Fall of Pattisons
But all was not well in the world of Scotch. There were rumours of financial problems at Pattisons as early as 1894, but these were papered over during a period of surging sales. However, in May 1898, there was a hint of things to come when the whisky company J & G Stewart went into liquidation.
On 5 December 1898 Pattisons ceased payment when it ran out of cash; its preference shares falling 55%. A few days later the Clydesdale Bank refused to extend credit to the company, forcing it into bankruptcy. When the Company’s books were scrutinised, the huge sum of £500,000 (£50m today) could not be accounted for. The bankruptcy hit unsecured creditors of the Company, causing further failures across the industry and among suppliers. Whisky prices fell and distillery construction came to a grinding halt.
The Great Whisky Swindle
The brothers were accused of embezzlement and fraud on a grand scale. At their trial, which was a major media event at the time, it emerged that the Pattisons were swindlers of the first rank, pursuing every accounting scam in the book. They had overvalued the Company’s property assets. They inflated the value of their stored whisky and they had paid dividends out of capital rather than income.
It was not only the books that were cooked. The Company was diddling its own drinkers by selling them dodgy whisky! Cheap grain whisky was mixed with small quantities of quality malt and sold as a premier product at high prices.
The brothers were convicted of fraud in 1901; Robert receiving a jail sentence of 18 months in Perth Prison and his younger brother nine months. The entire whisky industry came under intense scrutiny for lax practices and was severely criticised.
End of the Bubble
The glory days of whisky were over (for now). Glen Elgin distillery had opened in May 1900, but closed only five months later. No new distillery was built in Scotland until the Tullibardine distillery, constructed half a century later in 1949, indicating that the dramatic increase in production of the 1890s was based on absurdly optimistic projections of demand growth.
The 1890s Whisky Bubble highlights how investors can be carried away by the prevailing fad – be it resources, property, technology or whisky. Recent historically high consumption growth rates are projected to continue ad infinitum, with capacity expanded accordingly. The aftermath can be a very painful experience, even for the best operators in the industry. Hence, timing is more important than in steadier, less commoditized, growth sectors. We believe that an historical perspective is very important in investment, but care must also be taken not to become prisoners of recent history.
The bankruptcy of Pattisons underlines the risks of investing in fast-growing companies with a limited performance record which float on the stock market during boom conditions, and are dominated by a sales/marketing culture. When entrepreneurs start to display a flashy lifestyle and/or diversify into areas where they have no experience, this must be heeded.
At Stewart Investors we stress the importance of identifying extreme overvaluation in stock markets to preserve client wealth. We remain focused on the potential downside of any investment as much as the upside.
This material is for general information purposes only. It does not constitute investment or financial advice and does not take into account any specific investment objectives, financial situation or needs. This is not an offer to provide asset management services, is not a recommendation or an offer or solicitation to buy, hold or sell any security or to execute any agreement for portfolio management or investment advisory services and this material has not been prepared in connection with any such offer. Before making any investment decision you should consider, with the assistance of a financial advisor, your individual investment needs, objectives and financial situation.
We have taken reasonable care to ensure that this material is accurate, current, and complete and fit for its intended purpose and audience as at the date of publication. No assurance is given or liability accepted regarding the accuracy, validity or completeness of this material and we do not undertake to update it in future if circumstances change.
To the extent this material contains any expression of opinion or forward-looking statements, such opinions and statements are based on assumptions, matters and sources believed to be true and reliable at the time of publication only. This material reflects the views of the individual writers only. Those views may change, may not prove to be valid and may not reflect the views of everyone at First Sentier Investors.
About First Sentier Investors
References to ‘we’, ‘us’ or ‘our’ are references to First Sentier Investors, a global asset management business which is ultimately owned by Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group (MUFG). Our investment teams operate under the trading name of Stewart Investors which is part of the First Sentier Investors group.
We communicate and conduct business through different legal entities in different locations. This material is communicated in:
- Australia and New Zealand by First Sentier Investors (Australia) IM Limited, authorised and regulated in Australia by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (AFSL 289017; ABN 89 114 194311)
- European Economic Area by First Sentier Investors (Ireland) Limited, authorised and regulated in Ireland by the Central Bank of Ireland (CBI ref no. C182306; Registered office: 70 Sir John Rogerson’s Quay, Dublin 2, Ireland; Company no. 629188).
- Hong Kong by First Sentier Investors (Hong Kong) Limited and has not been reviewed by the Securities & Futures Commission in Hong Kong. First Sentier Investors and Stewart Investors are business names of First Sentier Investors (Hong Kong) Limited.
- Singapore by First Sentier Investors (Singapore) (Company no. 196900420D) and has not been reviewed by the Monetary Authority of Singapore. First Sentier Investors (registration number 53236800B) and Stewart Investors (registration number 53310114W) are business divisions of First Sentier Investors (Singapore).
- Japan by First Sentier Investors (Japan) Limited, authorised and regulated by the Financial Service Agency (Director of Kanto Local Finance Bureau (Registered Financial Institutions) No.2611).
- United Kingdom by First Sentier Investors (UK) Funds Limited, authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA ref no. 143359; Registered office: Finsbury Circus House, 15 Finsbury Circus, London EC2M 7EB; Company no. 2294743).
- United States by First Sentier Investors (US) LLC, authorised and regulated by the Securities Exchange Commission (RIA 801-93167).
- In other jurisdictions, where this document may lawfully be issued, by First Sentier Investors International IM Limited, authorised and regulated in the UK by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA ref no. 122512; Registered office: 23 St. Andrew Square, Edinburgh, EH2 1BB; Company no. SC079063).
To the extent permitted by law, MUFG and its subsidiaries are not liable for any loss or damage as a result of reliance on any statement or information contained in this document. Neither MUFG nor any of its subsidiaries guarantee the performance of any investment products referred to in this document or the repayment of capital. Any investments referred to are not deposits or other liabilities of MUFG or its subsidiaries, and are subject to investment risk, including loss of income and capital invested.