‘Our descendants doubtless will laugh at the human insanity of our Age, that in our times the tulip-flowers have been so revered.’
(Theodorus Schrevelius, 1648)1
The mania for buying and selling tulip bulbs in the Netherlands during the 17th century was arguably the earliest asset bubble in history and the precursor of financial manias over the following centuries. Tulipmania still provides valuable lessons for investors today.
Dutch Economic Miracle (The Golden Age)
The Dutch economy grew spectacularly in the 16th and early 17th centuries as foreign trade with the East Indies boomed. Amsterdam became the centre of global capitalism with a stock exchange, savings bank and thriving consumer market. The art market ballooned; Dutch culture of the Golden Age was mirrored in the paintings of Rembrandt and Vermeer. Gardens and gardening became popular and the Dutch fell in love with one particular flower – the tulip.
The tulip was introduced into Europe in the 16th century from the Ottoman Empire. First cultivated by the nobility, its popularity quickly spread, reflected in a catalogue of 1612, which included 100 plates of the flower. The Dutch middle-class were soon intoxicated with the tulip.
As demand for bulbs grew, prices rose, encouraging the cultivation of new varieties. The popularity of highly prized tulips, such as flamed and striped blooms like the Semper Augustus2, spread across Northern Europe and western parts of Germany and there was rising demand for bulbs in France.3
In the early 1630s, Dutch horticulturists became increasingly entrepreneurial, renting land for cultivation and significantly increasing supply.4 At the same time, the minimum number of bulbs an individual could buy dropped. Bulbs could be bought by the basket, pound or even individually, boosting demand significantly as many more people could afford to enter the market.
By the winter of 1635, buyers included a broad range of the population, from merchants and shopkeepers to skilled workers and artisans.5 The historian Goldgar notes that buyers were mostly merchants and skilled craftsmen, rather than nobles, and they were based in cities rather than the countryside. In Haarlem, a town close to Amsterdam, they included manufacturers, lawyers, surgeons, doctors, notaries, artists, silversmiths and a variety of craftsmen.6 In other words, the bubble was limited to those with access to capital. Six companies and a number of partnerships were set up especially to buy and sell tulips.7
At the time, there was no official market for trading bulbs, like a stock exchange. Deals were conducted by private arrangement at auctions in gardens, or at informal and formal sales in inns, in a similar way to the trading of company shares in the coffee-houses of London in the 1690s.8
The frenzy for bulb trading was relatively short-lived and reached its peak during the winter months of 1636/7. Rising prices attracted speculators into the market, increasing transaction volumes and pushing prices further into bubble territory.
A contributing factor was the development of a futures market which became the primary focus of trading.9 This was an important piece of financial engineering and contributed significantly to the bubble. Futures were not a new phenomenon in the Dutch Republic as Baltic grain futures dated back to the mid-16th century.
Prices of bulbs continued to rise in early 1637. Switsers, one of the most popular varieties, rose from 125 florins per pound on 31 December 1636 to a high of 1500 on 3 February 1637 – a 12-fold increase in the space of a month.10 This was the peak of the market. Prices collapsed in early February 1637, the fall beginning in Haarlem, where many investors were based.
Goldgar has convincingly argued that some aspects of the tulip bubble, and its impact, have been exaggerated by later commentators who did not base their accounts on contemporary historical sources. However, Tulipmania was perceived as something remarkable and unprecedented by contemporaries.
The mania spilled out of the financial world to influence broader Dutch culture. Jan Brueghel the Younger depicted bulb traders as monkeys in his painting A Satire of Tulip Mania and, in Wagon of Fools, Hendrik Pot painted them as a ‘Ship of Fools.’
(Jan Brueghel the Younger, Satire on Tulip Mania, c. 1640. Source: Wikipedia)
Many contemporaries were bamboozled by the bubble. They had known religious frenzies in the past, but a mania focused on a tulip bulb! What particularly concerned them was how it undermined their notion of ‘value’ - how could a tulip bulb suddenly be worth a sum equivalent to a tract of land or the annual wages of a skilled worker.11 The large number of pamphlets published in the wake of the bubble, criticising the folly of investors, was a reflection of this unease.
Perhaps surprisingly, the Dutch economy did not suffer significantly from the collapse. The amount of debt taken on to invest was not significant enough to cause a major credit crunch. Individual investors did, of course, make significant losses, especially if they purchased bulbs near the top of the market. It has been argued, however, that rather than an economic crisis, the impact was more subtle, contributing to a breakdown of honour and a destruction of trust, with significant long-term effects on Dutch society.
Tulipmania became a symbol of the ‘madness of crowds’, often cited as a warning during the asset bubbles that followed. It was the first appearance in history of a new financial and cultural phenomenon, an important milestone in the history of the modern financial world. Indeed it could be argued that tulipmania was an early sign of the ‘blooming’ of modernity.
(Sotheby’s technician with flower still life by Jan Brueghel the Elder. Source: Getty)
Lessons for Investors
The earliest bubble was an unusual one - it was focused on a plant, rather than the shares of a company or a precious metal. Nonetheless, it offers a number of lessons for investors today. It shows how a combination of factors, including an extended period of economic growth, plentiful liquidity, financial engineering and a group of new investors can produce an asset bubble.
At Stewart Investors we believe it is important to identify and acknowledge asset bubbles. By applying strict valuation discipline, we aim to avoid paying excessive prices for shares in the companies in which we invest.
We believe our first duty as investors is to preserve our clients’ capital. Along with our emphasis on stewardship and focus on the quality of franchise and financials, an important aspect of doing this is identifying and avoiding extreme levels of valuation.
This document has been prepared for general information purposes only and is intended to provide a summary of the subject matter covered. It does not purport to be comprehensive or to give advice. The views expressed are the views of the writer at the time of issue and may change over time. This is not an offer document, and does not constitute an offer, invitation, investment recommendation or inducement to distribute or purchase securities, shares, units or other interests or to enter into an investment agreement. No person should rely on the content and/or act on the basis of any matter contained in this document.
This document is confidential and must not be copied, reproduced, circulated or transmitted, in whole or in part, and in any form or by any means without our prior written consent. The information contained within this document has been obtained from sources that we believe to be reliable and accurate at the time of issue but no representation or warranty, express or implied, is made as to the fairness, accuracy or completeness of the information. We do not accept any liability for any loss arising whether directly or indirectly from any use of this document.
References to “we” or “us” are references to Stewart Investors. Stewart Investors is a trading name of First Sentier Investors (UK) Funds Limited, First Sentier Investors International IM Limited and First Sentier Investors (Ireland) Limited. First Sentier Investors entities referred to in this document are part of First Sentier Investors, a member of MUFG, a global financial group. First Sentier Investors includes a number of entities in different jurisdictions. MUFG and its subsidiaries do not guarantee the performance of any investment or entity referred to in this document or the repayment of capital. Any investments referred to are not deposits or other liabilities of MUFG or its subsidiaries, and are subject to investment risk including loss of income and capital invested.
Reference to specific securities (if any) is included for the purpose of illustration only and should not be construed as a recommendation to buy or sell. Reference to the names of any company is merely to explain the investment strategy and should not be construed as investment advice or a recommendation to invest in any of those companies.
Hong Kong and Singapore
In Hong Kong, this document is issued by First Sentier Investors (Hong Kong) Limited and has not been reviewed by the Securities & Futures Commission in Hong Kong. In Singapore, this document is issued by First Sentier Investors (Singapore) whose company registration number is 196900420D. This advertisement or publication has not been reviewed by the Monetary Authority of Singapore. Stewart Investors is a business name of First Sentier Investors (Hong Kong) Limited. Stewart Investors (registration number 53310114W) is a business division of First Sentier Investors (Singapore).
In Australia, this document is issued by First Sentier Investors (Australia) IM Limited AFSL 289017 ABN 89 114 194 311 (FSI AIM). Stewart Investors is a trading name of FSI AIM.
This document is not a financial promotion. In the United Kingdom, this document is issued by First Sentier Investors (UK) Funds Limited which is authorised and regulated in the UK by the Financial Conduct Authority (registration number 143359). Registered office: Finsbury Circus House, 15 Finsbury Circus, London, EC2M 7EB, number 2294743.
European Economic Area (“EEA”)
In the EEA, this document is issued by First Sentier Investors (Ireland) Limited which is authorised and regulated in Ireland by the Central Bank of Ireland (registered number C182306) in connection with the activity of receiving and transmitting orders. Registered office: 70 Sir John Rogerson’s Quay, Dublin 2, Ireland, number 629188.
In certain jurisdictions the distribution of this material may be restricted. The recipient is required to inform themselves about any such restrictions and observe them. By having requested this document and by not deleting this email and attachment, you warrant and represent that you qualify under any applicable financial promotion rules that may be applicable to you to receive and consider this document, failing which you should return and delete this e-mail and all attachments pertaining thereto. In the Middle East, this material is communicated by First Sentier Investors (Singapore).
If in doubt, you are recommended to consult a party licensed by the Capital Markets Authority (“CMA”) pursuant to Law No. 7/2010 and the Executive Regulations to give you the appropriate advice. Neither this document nor any of the information contained herein is intended to and shall not lead to the conclusion of any contract whatsoever within Kuwait.
UAE - Dubai International Financial Centre (DIFC)
Within the DIFC this material is directed solely at Professional Clients as defined by the DFSA’s COB Rulebook.
By having requested this document and / or by not deleting this email and attachment, you warrant and represent that you qualify under the exemptions contained in Article 2 of the Emirates Securities and Commodities Authority Board Resolution No 37 of 2012, as amended by decision No 13 of 2012 (the “Mutual Fund Regulations”). By receiving this material you acknowledge and confirm that you fall within one or more of the exemptions contained in Article 2 of the Mutual Fund Regulations.
United States of America
In the United States, this document is issued by First Sentier Investors International IM Limited, as SEC registered investment adviser. Stewart Investors is the trading name of First Sentier Investors International IM Limited. This material is solely for the attention of institutional, professional, qualified or sophisticated investors and distributors who qualify as qualified purchasers under the Investment Company Act of 1940 (hereafter the “1940 Act”), as accredited investors under Rule 501 of SEC Regulation D under the US Securities Act of 1933 (“1933 Act), and as qualified eligible persons as defined under CFTC Regulation 4.7. It is not to be distributed to the general public, private customers or retail investors.
In other jurisdictions where this document may lawfully be issued, this document is issued by First Sentier Investors International IM Limited which is authorised and regulated in the UK by the Financial Conduct Authority (registration number 122512). Registered office 23 St. Andrew Square, Edinburgh, EH2 1BB number SC079063.